The last time it came up I didn't really feel like polluting (or further polluting) the board with our back and forth bullstuff so I backed out--since you have a well deserved reputation for being a crank about argument and The Hostess had been more than patient.
I find Surdyka to have been discredited. She lied about several things, including things she didn't need to lie about (her participation in the Olympics for instance, or the pop pop pop, maybe even the amount of rain that was falling).
Lie about one thing, lie about everything. If you feel you want to cherry pick from her testimony/story--feel free. It's part of the jury instructions, I believe. But what you can't do is use that cherry picked stuff to attack other posters who've looked at the same evidence and testimony as you have and simply come to their own decision.
You contribute too much value here to do that.
And I'm glad to see you've been examining your thoughts about GZ's stories in light of what the actual professionals testified to. Doesn't really make me feel any better...since I've been saying the same thing about stress and stories for months now...